Chicago Rentals • 1-5 Units • Freeze • Water

Chicago rental property insurance — landlord coverage for 1-5 unit buildings.

Chicago landlords carry winter freeze, water damage and older-building risk that a homeowners policy was never built for. We place dwelling-fire and landlord policies for single-family rentals, two-flats, three-flats and 1-5 unit properties, and a real broker calls you within the hour.

Straight talk

Fill in the form and one licensed broker from Johal Insurance Brokers calls you back within the hour. You won’t get a hundred calls from random brokers. You’ll get one call from us, and we’ll handle everything start to finish.

A real broker calls you within the hour
The Commercial Property Owner's Guide to Insurance Costs →
🧮 Estimate Your Property Premium →
See how much you can save
Four fields. No long form. A real broker reviews it and calls you within the hour.
No spam. No robocalls. One licensed broker calls you within the hour. CA, TX, IL, MO, WI & LA risks only.

How to Get the Fastest Quote Possible

If this is a brand new purchase, you can ignore this. But if you already have existing coverage, contact your current insurance company and request something called a loss run. It will be emailed to you and must be submitted when we quote. We recommend getting it now — whether you go with us or shop elsewhere, any broker will need it. This is one of the biggest things that slows down getting a property quote.

Sixty seconds to carriers competing for you

Three steps. One real broker. No call center, no runaround.

1Tell us about your rental property

The quick form above — four fields, that’s it.

2We shop A-rated carriers

A real broker puts carriers in competition for your business.

3You pick the winner

A broker calls you within the hour with your options and straight advice.

Why a broker beats a single carrier

Every name below sells you one policy — take it or leave it. We work for you, not a carrier, so we put all of them plus more A-rated companies in competition for your rental property and make them fight over your price. Competition is how premiums come down.

They sell one policybiBERKHiscoxGEICOTravelersThe HartfordLiberty MutualChubbNationwideProgressiveState FarmAmTrustGuardWe shop them all + more They sell one policybiBERKHiscoxGEICOTravelersThe HartfordLiberty MutualChubbNationwideProgressiveState FarmAmTrustGuardWe shop them all + more

What drives your Chicago rental property insurance rate

Winter water damage leads the pricing in Chicago. After that, underwriters price the building itself and who lives in it.

  • Winter freeze and pipes — A vacant or underheated unit in a Chicago winter can burst pipes in hours; freeze is the loss that takes 1-5 unit buildings offline.
  • Water and older plumbing — Two-flats and greystones often have original plumbing, stacked bathrooms and flat roofs — water damage is the claim that drives price.
  • Heat and vacancy — If heat fails, plumbing freezes. Vacant units between tenants are a different risk than occupied ones, and long vacancies often need a vacancy endorsement.
  • Loss of rents — If a freeze, fire or water loss makes units uninhabitable, loss-of-rents coverage replaces the income — sized from your rent roll, so carriers ask for it.
  • Building age and updates — Roof, wiring, plumbing and HVAC update years decide both price and which carriers will take the risk on older Chicago housing stock.
  • Porches, decks and liability — Rear porches and shared stairs are a Chicago-specific liability exposure; tell your broker about decks, porches and any open violations.
  • Owner- vs tenant-occupied — A two-flat you live in prices differently than a fully tenant-occupied fourplex — tell your broker which units you occupy.
  • Section 8 and tenant mix — Subsidized tenancies are writable with the right carriers; flag them on the rent roll so we select the market that will take the risk.

A complete landlord package for a Chicago rental usually means a DP-3 dwelling policy with replacement cost, loss of rents and landlord liability — with freeze, water and vacancy terms reviewed carefully before you bind.

We shop your rental property with multiple A-rated carriers and show you exactly what each one covers, so you can compare price and coverage side by side before you buy.

Get My Quote
Loss of rents coverage, explained →

Chicago landlord rules that affect insurance

Most Chicago rentals fall under the Residential Landlord and Tenant Ordinance (RLTO). The city's RLTO page says the ordinance covers most rental properties except units in owner-occupied buildings with six units or less, plus listed exceptions such as hotels, dormitories and owner-occupied co-ops. Landlords must attach a summary of the ordinance to each written lease or renewal. Separately, the Chicago Heat Ordinance requires landlords to supply heat in designated cold-weather months and to keep heating equipment in working order; the Buildings Department notes that lack of heat puts plumbing at risk of freezing.

Those rules are not insurance — but heat, habitability and vacancy are exactly what carriers underwrite in this market. Shared-housing registration is a different regime and applies only to stays of 31 days or fewer. If any unit is used as a short-term rental, tell your broker so the policy matches the actual use. Confirm current RLTO, heat and shared-housing requirements on chicago.gov.

Official sources: City of Chicago — Residential Landlord and Tenant Ordinance · City of Chicago — Chicago Heat Ordinance · City of Chicago — Shared Housing Registrations

Who we insure

Landlords across the Chicago metro — two-flats and three-flats in Wicker Park, Logan Square, Pilsen, Bridgeport and Humboldt Park, single-family rentals in Beverly and Edison Park, and small portfolios from Lincoln Park to Oak Park and Evanston.

Also serving: Los Angeles rental property insurance · San Diego rental property insurance · San Francisco rental property insurance · Chicago Airbnb insurance · 1-5 Unit Rental Property Insurance in every city

We answer when you call — and we fight at renewal

We pick up when you call. We fight for your price at renewal, not just year one. And we tell you the truth even when it costs us the sale. If your current price is fair, we’ll say so. If you’re overpaying, we’ll show you by how much.

What we need to quote your Chicago rental — and straight answers

What information do you need to quote my Chicago rental property?

Send as much of this as you have — a broker will help fill the gaps:

  • Property address(es), and whether any unit is owner-occupied
  • Named insured (you or your LLC) and mailing address
  • Year built, construction type and square footage
  • Roof age, and the years electrical, plumbing and HVAC were last updated
  • Number of units and how many are currently rented
  • Annual gross rents or a current rent roll
  • Any Section 8 or subsidized tenancies
  • Porches, decks, boilers or shared amenities
  • Current declarations page and expiration date, if insured now
  • Prior losses, or 3-5 years of loss runs from your current carrier

Do I need a DP-3 policy or a commercial policy?

Most 1-5 unit rentals belong on a dwelling-fire policy — usually DP-3, the special form: open-peril coverage on the building, replacement cost if you insure to value, plus loss of rents and landlord liability. Larger buildings, or several properties bundled into one portfolio, often fit better on a commercial package. We place both, so we'll tell you honestly which side of the line your property sits on.

What is loss of rents coverage?

If a covered loss like a freeze, fire or water damage makes units uninhabitable, loss of rents coverage replaces the rental income you lose while the property is repaired. It's sized from your rent roll, which is one reason carriers ask for it up front.

How does winter freeze affect my Chicago landlord policy?

Freeze and water are the losses that take Chicago 1-5 unit buildings offline. If heat fails, pipes burst — and the city's own Heat Ordinance page flags that risk. Vacant units between tenants are the worst case. A landlord policy still has to be rated for rental use; freeze is not a reason to stay on a homeowners form. We look at heat source, occupancy and whether someone can check the building in a cold snap.

Do you insure Section 8 rentals?

Yes. Several of our carriers write subsidized tenancies, and we can place Section 8 rentals. Just flag it when you send the rent roll — it affects carrier selection, not whether we can place you.

Should I require my tenants to carry renters insurance?

It's a good idea, and many Chicago landlords do. Your policy covers the building and your own liability — not the tenant's belongings or their personal liability. A renters policy also gives the tenant liability coverage if they accidentally cause a fire or water loss, which keeps smaller claims off your record.

How fast can I get a quote?

Most Chicago rentals are quoted the same day. A licensed broker calls you back — usually within the hour during business hours (Monday-Friday, 9-5 Pacific) — and we put multiple A-rated carriers in competition for your account.

Send your details and documents to service@johalinsurancebrokers.com, call (805) 380-5564, or use the form at the top of this page. Checklists for every property type: commercial insurance quote checklist.

Ready to see what multiple carriers will do for your Chicago rental?

One licensed broker calls you within the hour. No call center.

See How Much I Can Save